s: Are my feelings towards straight women out of place?

Ok I'm gay but I needed to answer this because I am the same way towards straight men. It's highly natural. I think what you're trying to say is you prefer feminine women over masculine women. That's perfectly normal for s, as liking masculine men is normal for gay men. The whole reason we are gay in the first place is because we have an attraction to the same . I personally find it weirder if a gay man prefers feminine guys, or if a prefers masculine women.